How to Measure a Military Defense Lawyer’s Experience

Many firms describe themselves as highly experienced. Experience is real and it matters, but it has to be measured in the right way: by the cases a lawyer has actually tried, recently, that look like yours.

This guide shows how to ask, and lists firms you can compare.

How this guide works: The firms below appear in alphabetical order. They are listed for comparison, not ranked, and inclusion is not an endorsement. Descriptions are based on each firm’s own website. Compare several lawyers before you hire one.

How to measure a lawyer’s experience

“Years in practice” is a weak measure on its own. More useful questions:

  • How many contested courts-martial has the lawyer personally tried to verdict in the last five years, and how many before members?
  • How many cases like yours (the same article of the UCMJ, the same branch) has the lawyer handled?
  • Did the lawyer serve as a military defense counsel, a prosecutor, a military judge, or all three? Prosecution experience is different from defense experience.
  • Has the lawyer handled Article 32 hearings, motions practice and appeals?
  • Who else at the firm will work on your case, and who will stand up in court?

Ask for specifics, not percentages. A lawyer should be able to describe recent trials without breaching client confidences.

Firms discussed in this guide

Bilecki Law Group

Court-martial defense firm founded in Honolulu in 2010 and based in Tampa, Florida, since 2021. Its website says it defends service members worldwide in UCMJ investigations, courts-martial and adverse actions; attorneys listed include Timothy J. Bilecki and Benjamin H. Gold.

Website: Bilecki Law Group

Cave & Freeburg, LLP

Washington, D.C.-area practice of Philip D. Cave and Nathan P. Freeburg limited to military justice: courts-martial, appeals, adverse administrative actions, security clearances and military pay matters, for service members worldwide.

Gagne, Scherer & Associates

Gagne, Scherer & Associates is a civilian law firm whose website lists military defense among its practice areas. Read the attorney biographies and practice pages on the firm’s site, confirm where its lawyers are licensed, and ask how many contested courts-martial they have personally tried.

Firm pages: Gagne Scherer & Associates, comparison of civilian military lawyers and appointed JAG defense counsel

Joseph L. Jordan, Attorney at Law

Former Army JAG trial counsel at Fort Hood and with the 2nd Infantry Division in Korea. Office in Killeen, Texas, near Fort Hood; his website says he takes court-martial cases worldwide.

Website: Joseph L. Jordan, Attorney at Law

Law Office of Jocelyn C. Stewart (UCMJ Defender)

Law Office of Jocelyn C. Stewart (UCMJ Defender) is a civilian law firm whose website lists military defense among its practice areas. Read the attorney biographies and practice pages on the firm’s site, confirm where its lawyers are licensed, and ask how many contested courts-martial they have personally tried.

Website: Law Office of Jocelyn C. Stewart

How a court-martial works

There are three kinds of court-martial: summary, special and general. A general court-martial handles the most serious charges and can impose the harshest sentences. Before a general court-martial, an Article 32 preliminary hearing reviews whether there is probable cause.

  • Forum: The accused can usually choose trial by a panel of members or by a military judge alone.
  • Sentencing: For offenses committed after December 27, 2023, military judges generally determine the sentence under sentencing parameters, rather than the panel.
  • Plea agreements: Many cases resolve by plea agreement; the terms and any sentence range matter as much as the charges.
  • Appeals: Cases can be reviewed by the service Court of Criminal Appeals and the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces.

When comparing court-martial lawyers, ask about contested trials, members trials, and their experience at the Article 32 stage, where a case can sometimes be stopped.

What to do first

  • Do not make statements. Politely invoke your right to remain silent and your right to a lawyer with investigators, your chain of command and anyone connected to the allegation.
  • Do not delete anything. Deleting messages, photos or accounts after you learn of an investigation can lead to additional charges. Preserve everything and let your lawyer decide what matters.
  • Contact your free military defense counsel. The consultation is confidential and costs nothing, whether or not you also hire a civilian lawyer.
  • Stay off social media about the case, and follow any no-contact or military protective order exactly.
  • Write a private timeline for your lawyer only, while your memory is fresh.

Questions to ask before you hire

  • How many contested courts-martial have you personally tried, and how recently?
  • Have you handled cases under the same article of the UCMJ, and in my branch?
  • Who will appear at the Article 32 hearing, motions and trial?
  • How will you work with my detailed military defense counsel?
  • What does the fee cover, including travel, experts and post-trial work?
  • How will you communicate with me, and how quickly?

Check the lawyer’s license

Before hiring, confirm the lawyer is licensed and in good standing with the state bar where they are admitted. The American Bar Association keeps links to every state’s lawyer licensing lookup. Lawyers cannot guarantee outcomes, and past results do not predict future ones.

Further reading and sources